[Newspeak Natterings: An occasional Contratimes feature highlighting the corruption of language and thought. Today, President Bush and Harriet Miers.]
I am pleased and not a bit surprised that my readers have not inquired as to why I've been silent about Ms. Harriet Miers since her nomination. (I was quite vocal about Mr. John Roberts.) Partly my silence was a mere marketing trick; I wanted to provide readers with something different and unpredictable. Indeed, the blogosphere was trembling under the weight of all the Miers missives.
But I also had a hunch, and at least one reader knows this, that Ms. Miers would not even make the first cut. How could she be acceptable in the eyes of conservatives, when it was Harry Reid, Democrat from Nevada, who told the President that Ms. Miers might make a good Supreme Court nominee? It was doomed from the very first utterance, and one can only speculate about the political and partisan intrigue that occurred in the minds of Reid and Bush. And the James Dobson thing was a whole mind-boggling fiasco.
Predictably, the left is now spinning everything this way: The extreme right has too much power; Ms. Miers was too moderate for those extremists. Willingly ignoring the fact that not one conservative pundit knew a thing about Ms. Miers' positions, Democrats nonetheless shall go trolling with such scrawny bait. And they shall never tell you that the problem for most conservatives was that Ms. Miers appeared to be a judicial lightweight. And that is exactly what she was.
But much of my silence was because of embarrassment. The nomination was so anemic as to appear like a ruse. With the sort of rhetoric President Bush offered in presenting Ms. Miers to the public, I nominate, in a prophetic way, the following dialogue as Newspeak Natterings #2:
President Bush: Today, November 4, 2005, I would like to announce my nomination of Harriet Beecher Stowe Jr. to the position of associate justice of the United States Supreme Court. I find Ms. Stowe Jr. to be supremely qualified ...
David Gregory, NBC News: Excuse me, Mr. President, but did you not say in your announcement in September that Ms. Miers was the "most qualified person" you "could find" for the position?
President Bush: Well, if you'd let me finish, I'd speak to that. What I said was that Ms. Miers was the most qualified person, but I did not say that she was the ONLY most qualified person. You read between the lines, David, and I believe the American people know what I meant.
David Gregory: Yes, Mr. President, but with all due respect, you did say that she...
President Bush: And I meant that she was the most qualified person I could find. I didn't say there weren't other most qualified people. She was just the most qualified person I found. I imagine if I had to broaden my search, if I had looked beyond the Oval Office, the West Wing, I'd have found perhaps a bunch of other most-qualified people too, as well, even also. And since September I've found some others; the American people understand that. And today I have found Ms. Stowe Jr. to be another most-qualified person that I could find. She comes from an important family line, and she, well, the American people understand that this is hard work, and I am working hard with Ms. Stowe, who is a woman of integrity and conviction, to bring before the American people a viable candidate to the Supreme Court ...
David Gregory: Yes, yes, Mr. President that is all well and good, but are you saying that Ms. Miers was the most well qualified nominee you could find that just happened not to be viable? What assurances can you give to the American people that Ms. Stowe Jr. is viable?
President Bush: I just did, I said she was viable, and she is. Let the American people judge for themselves. I have confidence in the American people, and I am confident that when the American people get to know Ms. Stowe Jr. like I do, like I have, through this process, they will agree with me. That she is a good, decent, hardworking woman of conviction. And now I would like to tell you a story about Ms. Stowe Jr.'s childhood, as she grew up in southern Maine, in Biddeford, ...
Ms. Stowe, whispering: That's Baltimore, sir, Baltimore, Maryland.
President Bush: Huh?
Ms. Stowe: Maryland, sir, I was raised in Maryland.
President Bush: Excuse me. Ms. Stowe's childhood in Biddeford, Maryland prepared her ...
Who knows what comes next?
Contratimes
1 comment:
BG-
Thanks for your kind words and serious thoughts over at our site. Watch that space. I will reply to your comment presently.
You have noticed something here that perplexes me about our President. He seems actually to believe that because he "understands" and because folks are "working really hard" that the constituency should be satisfied. I wonder if he's cool like that to his staff, "I understand and see that you're working really hard on this problem, what about that yellowcake in Niger?" I wish my supervisors demanded as little. His language is a curious tool.
You're doing good work out here. Thanks for it.
Post a Comment