But as one Boston commentator stated today (Michael Graham), Scooter Libby has been indicted for lying about telling the truth about a man who lied. In other words, Scooter Libby stated a truth – Mr. Joe Wilson's wife, Valerie Plame Wilson, was a CIA agent – and then lied about when he knew and shared that truth in apparent response to Mr. Wilson's own lies about his trip to Niger, his findings there, and who it was that sent him (among other things). On semantic grounds alone, the gist of this story is titillating: lying about telling the truth about a liar. But in the end, at least in the end of this day, no one is indicted for leaking the name of that particular CIA agent. The indictment is all about a post-crime crime. The first "crime" might not have ever occurred at all.
But there is one thing that is more disturbing than Mr. Libby's perjury. I shared this earlier at Occasional Outbursts, a blogging friend of Contratimes. I wrote:
Honestly, I plead ignorant on all counts. I’ve no reference point that is not framed by cynicism. The bottom line for me is this: There is a contradiction in the hearts of Democrats. No, it is not that they supported Bill Clinton when he committed the same crimes as Mr. Libby. It’s that they have wailed and moaned about the reckless, treasonous act of outing a CIA agent. The contradiction? The Democrats (particularly the most left-leaning Democrats) have historically HATED the CIA since time immemorial, seeing that agency as naught more than an extension of American imperialism and hegemony. Shame on the Democrats for this hypocrisy; and shame on the media for not pointing it out.
I am all for Scooter Libby receiving the punishment his alleged guilt deserves. But his treachery hardly bothers me when I compare his acts to the feigned concern for CIA secrecy suddenly sacrosanct among Democrats. Surely their posturing and umbrage is a treason of the mind.
Contratimes
©Bill Gnade 2005/Contratimes - All Rights Reserved.
3 comments:
Yes, odd that the CIA has become the "darlings" of the left. They suddenly are at the front lines in defending against any violation
of the agency's rules.
It's strange how fluid allegiances have become in today's political arena.
Alliances based on political expediency.
What actually happened is no longer important. What is important is which side of the partisan devide will gain in the public oppinion polls. Which side has a stacked deck in media representation.
Sends a cold chill up my spine just to think about it.
I think you're painting with pretty broad strokes and unfairly so. Maybe it's a generational presumption, but I do not and have not perceived any wholesale disdain or sudden love for the CIA among those (us?) who lean to the contemporary left. If anything, it's the hard right and those prone to conspiracy thinking who suspect the CIA. The CIA - or some agency with its function - is necessary, yet we must always be mindful and watchful of entities who operate in secret, even in support of democracy.
Frankly, I don't see the hypocrisy or mental treason that you try to finger here. I think your concern is a wee red herring before this relatively basic, alleged crime.
Thank you both for dropping by. JRB is indeed right; I am painting with broad strokes, but the picture I paint is, well, in a Van Gogh sort of way: It is gobbed and swept with paint, and yet it tells us something.
When I was a college student in the early 1980s, there was no more despised political entity (other than Ronald Reagan in general) than the CIA. Leftists frequently protested in the streets of Boston, decrying CIA activities in Central America, where the balance between the Contras and the Sandinistas was ostensibly being adversely affected. The CIA, Iran-Contra, Noriega; these were all associated with the CIA.
I still have leftist associates that recall those days with something approaching first love, or first hate.
Moreover, right after 9/11 I heard this from my leftist friends; that the CIA was responsible for creating Osama bin Laden, as he was one of the mujihadeen "trained" and "supported" by CIA operatives in a Cold War battle in Afghanistan. At no point have I ever heard one leftist associate speak fondly, respectfully or favorably of the CIA. Many, I believe, consider the CIA responsible for the Cold War stand-off, the undermining of the USSR, and the creation of super-power imbalance as a result of the USSR's downfall. Trust me when I say this: there are leftists who believe that NOT having the USSR (or some other super-power) hold America hegemony in check is not only a very bad thing, it is the very cause of 9/11. You see, it was the USSR that was able to confront and control radical Islam. Had the USA not been the only super-power in the world, Islamic rage would have been directed elsewhere. (I am not making this stuff up!)
The CIA's role then, in propping up dictators only to topple them for American gain; for undermining revolution and progressivistic programs; for weakening a functioning standoff between super-powers, all these things, among many others, have led most leftists to despise the CIA. Until now.
I am ready to admit that all I've written is based on anecdotal evidence. I readily concede that it might be a generational thing. But I know this then about my generation–those protestors of the CIA's involvement in Central America, Iran, and Afghanistan are the same folks marching against the Iraq War. They are Democrats, by and large.
Not that any of what I wrote should be taken as gospel. It is to be taken with a grain of salt. I am no expert; and my blogging of course is (by definition?) done in broad strokes. I can only share what I know, and what I can recall.
There really is something intellectually treasonous that my friends commit when they tell me on the one hand how evil the CIA is, and then tell me how evil it is that America's security has been compromised by the outing of an alleged CIA operative. I, personally, cannot hold these sorts of beliefs in consistent tension.
I am grateful for your thoughtful challenges to my overtly casual opinions.
Peace to you all,
BG
Post a Comment